Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Ecclesiology in the Understandings of Early Church Fathers


Rev. Dr. Sunni E. Mathew 

Mar Thoma Syrian Theological Seminary, 
Kottayam

Introduction


The title Church Fathers corresponds to those who labored to mould and make grow the faithful in the faith of the Church. Therefore, the early Church designated the title to those Bishops who dedicated their lives as
the strong proponents of right faith and practices and spent their time in teaching and building the faithful in this tradition. But in the later period this category also included those who were not bishops but were vigilant enough in the propagation of right faith (orthodoxy). The first three centuries correspond to the epoch of the apostles and the apostolic fathers (up to 300 C.E). They are those who are having either direct or indirect acquaintance with the apostles. This is also the period of martyrs, apologists. Church Fathers like Ignatius of Antioch, Clement of Rome, Ireneus of Lyon represent this epoch. The second period is considered as the golden period of the Church (C.E. 300 to 450). It was during this period the Church got liberated from persecutions. During this time a number of churches came up in different quarters in and outside the Roman kingdom. Once the Church became officially recognized and patronized, benefits and luxuries poured into the Church. In the midst of the newly acquired benefits and luxury Church lost its vigor and became ethically vulnerable. Yet it was during this time that the Church developed much of its theological, Christological and ecclesiological understandings and attained greater clarity in that matters. We could also see the development of an ethical consciousness that challenged degenerating moral condition of the general Christian populace. Committed Church Fathers consciously and vehemently stressed that the Church to become a value oriented community that stand firm as a counter culture. Fathers like Athanasius of Alexandria, Baselius of Caesarea, Gregory of Nyssa, Gregorgy of Nazianzus, Cyril of Jerusalem, John Chrysostom of Constantinople, Mar Aprem of Syria, Mar Aphraat of Persia represent this epoch. The third era starts from 451 C.E. It is the period of the divided Church following the Synod of Chalcedon. It was during this period the ecclesiological controversy regarding the authority of Pope became a serious matter of debate. This paper tries to briefly look into the ecclesiological understanding during the first two periods.
Importance of the Church Fathers

The period of Early Church Fathers occupy a significant place in the formation of ecclesiological understanding. It is through them we get the glimpses of the ecclesiological vision and its depth, diverse nature, and also the interpretations of the Scripture of the apostles. Their thoughts and faith therefore becomes a yardstick to form the faith and practices of the Church. As a result we could call their understandings as the foundation for theological and ecclesiological vision of the Church.  
Ecclesiology is the theological doctrine on the understanding of the Church. It represents the self understanding of the Church regarding what it means to be the Church.It also encompasses its vision on the mission of the Church. It clarifies the nature and mission of the Church in relation with the past, present and future. It looks back into the past and looks forward into the future and concentrates on the present. As a result, it tries to visionize the future of the Church as well as the future Church. Ecclesiological understanding involves a historical appraisal of the development of the idea of the Church through the history. Therefore it has continuity. Ecclesiology makes a constant and consistent build up in conformity with the basic foundations of the understanding of the Church. At the same time, it is engaging in ongoing confrontation with the already developed ideas developing new understanding or providing clarity to the already existing ones. Period of the early teachers of faith (Church Fathers) is an example for such a development.

Church as the New Temple

Didascalia is the work that came up towards the first decade of the third century. It is pregnant with a number of valuable understandings regarding the early Church. The author of this profound work considers the Church as the new temple of God. In his view, the Jerusalem temple and the tabernacle are the forerunners of the Christian Church. Hence the Church should exhibit all the qualities of the holy place. At the same time all attributes associated with them are applicable and appropriate for the Church also. In consequence he calls the Church as the living mountain, the throne of Glory, amazing household etc. He authenticates this approach through referring the words of the prophets.


This understanding regarding the Church calls to see and maintain the holiness of the Church. Church Father Origen in his expounding of the Gospel according to John, refers to the claim of Jesus which says that he would restore the temple within three days. In that he makes it clear that after the resurrection his disciples understood that the reference was regarding his own body. Origen reminds in that work that the Glory of God dwells in the temple. As the body of the first born Church is the temple. It is the dwelling place of the Glory of God. The following words of him testify this,

 But he spoke of the temple of His body. …This refers to the statement that the body of the Son is His temple. …whether the body which He received from the virgin, or that body of Christ which the Church is said to be, as we are said by the Apostle to be all members of His body… because as the temple had the glory of God dwelling in it, …could rightly be called in respect of His body or the Church, the temple containing the image. (Ante – Nicene Fathers  Vol. 9, p. 405)

St. Ephraem the Syriac Father who lived in the fourth century also view the Church as the temple of God. In his understanding the Church as the temple is not only unconquerable but it cannot be overrun by the powers of darkness.


Church as the witness of the Kingdom of God
Early Church was anticipating the immanent parousia. She awaited the speedy second coming of Christ. An attempt to have a literal interpretation of parousia led to a slacking in having a positive approach to creative transformation of the world. But slowly the Church realized the folliness of this literal interpretation of the imminent parousia. Even while strongly upholding the second coming of Christ, their understanding regarding the time of fulfillment began to undergo considerable change. They strongly maintained that the Kingdom of God inaugurated through Jesus will be consummated during his second coming. She taught that the Son of God (Logos) who existed in transcendence to history came into history, took flesh, lived, died, resurrected and ascended to heaven transcending the limitations of time and space in history. The very same Christ will come and liberate history to eternity. But the timing is not known to us. It is controlled by God alone. During the New Testament period this time was considered very imminent. Now with the flow of time, the Church tried to view it in a more realistic approach. For the Church which theologically viewed itself as the body of Christ, this provided more opportunities. Hence Church became a prophetic and theological symbol and witness of the Kingdom of God became deep-rooted. According to Origen,

Now the adornment of the world is the Church, Christ being her adornment, who is the first light of the world…Should anyone consider that the church is called the light of the world, .... including unbelievers, this may be true if the assertion is taken prophetically and theologically...(“Commentary on John,” Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 9, p. 380)

Church is a harmonized community in Christ and the people of God

If the historical flow of time was the contributing factor of the previously mentioned ecclesiological shift, development of controversies and dissensions within the Church became instrumental in producing clarity in another ecclesiological vision. Rooting on the fundamental conception of Church as the body of Christ, ecclesiological conceptions developed around the concept of united community in Christ that is being experienced in a more practical level. Through this, the Fathers exhorted to reconsider the destructive faith and practices arguments that dilapidate the community that ought to be united in self-emptying love. This approach provided clarity to the codification and permeation of orthodoxy in the context of heresies and dissentions. As a result Church came to be understood as the community of the faithful and the Fathers taught that the Church is the repository of the orthodoxy and the orthopraxis. That is the reason why Ignatius of Lyon, clarifies that while the Church hold on to the true faith, the heretics promulgate follies. He writes, “...the truth proclaimed by the church is immovable, and that the theories of these men are but tissues of falsehood.” (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 1, p. 330). In this understanding continuity of faith is very important. Therefore, Church cannot be contained to the present. It includes the community that was, that is and that will be.  Because, in his understanding Church is a witnessing community. One could also witness the deliberate urge to emphasize the community nature of the Church without denigrating the value of individuals within the Church and at the same time safeguarding the Church from falling into the trap of individualism.

Church as the Eucharistic Community

According to the Fathers it is not the external structures that makes the Church, but the worship. Church is a worshipping community. Worship was formulated within the Church community and the Church was edified through its worship. Ecclesiological visions were developed through the worship. That gave a direction to what should be the Church. The fundamental worship is the Eucharist. In the Eucharist, the Church discovers the nature of the Kingdom of God. This discovery moulds the Church as a Eucharistic community. That is the reason why Ireneus says that our teachings and the teachings of the Eucharist go hand in hand. The process of receiving the Kingdom through our self emptying submission in the Eucharist builds the Church continuously. Unity in the Eucharist through participation in the body and blood of Christ becomes the foundation for social relationships and their strength. When Ignatius of Antioch said, “It is profitable therefore, that you should live in unblemeable unity, that this ye may always enjoy communion with God” (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 1, p. 51),he was categorical in reminding us that unity is a must to experience communion with God.

Bishop is the one who is commissioned to lead this Eucharistic community. It is in the concept of unity of the Eucharistic community that he proclaims that where there is the Bishop, there is the Church. In the context of the docetic understanding that negated the real body of Christ, he emphasized that Eucharist becomes meaningful only where the community acknowledges along with the presiding bishop, the reality of the body of Christ. That is evident in the following words, “They are ashamed of the cross; they mock at the passion; they make a jest of the resurrection… These people abstain from Eucharist and from prayer. (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 1). We could also read this view in Justin Martyr,

  And this food is called among us as the Eucarista (Eucharist), of which no one is allowed to 
  partake but the man who believes that the things which we teach are true, ... For 
  not as common bread and common drink do we receive these; but in like manner 
  as Jesus Christ our Saviour, having been made flesh by the Word of God, had 
  both flesh and blood for our salvation… (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol.          1, p. 185)


According to the Docetics, body of Jesus was only a notion and not a reality. In consequence, participation in the Eucharist became the yardstick for orthodoxy and the concept of Church as the Eucharistic community attained more significance.

Church is eternal, mystical and eschatological


During the New Testament period itself Church was considered as the body of Christ. Biblical texts Romans 12, 1 Corinthians 12 and Ephesians 4 present Church as the body of Christ. This vision edified the Church. It acknowledged the diversified role and responsibility of the community. At the same time it emphasized the unity and interdependence of the members of the Church. As the body of Christ, Church has a heavenly nature.  Since Christ is eternal and is revealed in the history with the consummation coming in the eschatology, it was emphasized that Church is being revealed with its consummation in the eschatology. Even though the Church exists in the history as the witness of the Kingdom, Kingdom would only be fully realized in the eschatom.At the same time the eschatological Church is clearly manifested in the present Church. That is the basis of the mission of the Church. Hence Church is not a new phenomenon, but is in existence form eternity within the will of God. Clement of Rome testifies this through the following words,

     … if we do the will of our Father God, we shall be members of the first church, the Spiritual– 
    that which was created before sun and moon… and that the Books and the Apostles teach 
    that the church is not of  the present, but from the beginning. For it was spiritual, as was also 
    our Jesus, and was made manifest at the end of the days in order to save you. The Church 
    being spiritual, was made manifest in the flesh of Christ, ... (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol 9, p. 255)

He continues to say that doing the will of the Lord; we shall belong to the living Church, the Body of Christ, the Church that exists right from the beginning. Hermas, the Church Father who lived during the second century, in his famous work Shepherd portrays Church in an eschatological vision as an eternal reality (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 2, p. 13). In his understanding the fullness of the Church is attained at Christ’s own time. This conception acknowledges the place of those who earnestly labored in the unity of faith and love and those who were persecuted and martyred for the sake of Christ. It also gives room for repentance for those who fell from faith during the time of intense persecution. This understanding is open to the repenting apostates and exhibits the militant and triumphant natures of the Church. In short, the beginning of the Church is in eternity and it cannot cease to exist with in the course of history. This view directs the Church to the will of God at the beginning of history and leads it to eternity as the consummation of the Kingdom. So the Church exists now in the great tension between the already and yet to be nature. This eschatological nature of the Church became a strengthening tradition during the period of persecution. Passage of the historical time and the realization of the mistake of literal interpretation of the words of Christ has led the Church Fathers to make a re-reading and re-interpretation of the biblical understanding of the Church as the body of Christ.

Church as the ethical community


Growth of the Church continued in the midst of severe persecution. Bu the second century, a lot of misconceptions were rumored regarding various practices of the Church. Intension behind these romours was directed to destroy the Church. They presented the Church as the community of atheists engaging in immoral activities. In the midst of this damaging accusation that questions the foundational ethics of the Church, the Fathers insisted that Church should be an ethical community. They insisted that Church should be a model in their response to neighbors, marginalized, widows, helpless etc. Clement of Rome made it clear through these words,

       Let our whole body, then, be preserved in Christ Jesus; and let everyone be subject to 
     his neighbor according to the special gift bestowed upon him. Let the strong not despise 
    the weak, and let the weak show respect unto the strong. Let the rich man provide for 
    the wants of the poor; and let the poor man bless God, because He hath given him one 
    by whom his needs may be supplied… (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 1, p. 15)

We could see this emphasis in the epistle of Ignatius to Hero, when he wrote ‘Honour widows that are widows indeed. Be the friend of orphans; for God is “the Father of the Fatherless, and the judge of the widows”. (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 1, p. 113).  In the same letter he speaks about the equality of male and female. "Do not hold women in abomination, for they have given thee birth, and brought thee up. It is fitting, therefore, to love those that are the authors of our birth (but only in the Lord), in as much as a man can produce no children without a woman." (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 1, p. 114).  Clement of Alexandria in his work Paedagoges also clarifies this equality.

     For if God of both is one, the master of both is also one, one Church, …  marriage an 
    equal yoke, respiration, sight, hearing, knowledge, hope, obedience, love all alike… life 
   is common, have common graces and common salvation; … common therefore too to men 
  and women, is the name man. For this reason I think the Attics called, not boys 
  only, but girls paidarion, using it as word for common gender… the virtue of man 
   and woman is the same. (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 2, p.211)

He further makes it clear that, “As far as respects human nature, the woman doesnot possess one nature, and the man exhibits another, but the same, so also with virtue”. (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 2, p. 419).  Cyprian of Carthage is of the opinion that Church cannot go back to the sinful lifestyle because as the baptismal community it has been cleansed. Hence it cannot move away from the Kingdom style. "… being born of flesh, had been living in the practice of sins, was of the earth earthly, but had now begun to be of God and was animated by the Spirit of holiness. You yourself assuredly know and reollect … that life of virtue."  (Ante – Nicene Fathers Vol. 5, p.276).

Following the conversion of Constantine, Church became the den of luxury loving people. In such a context Fathers exhorted that the Church should remain as a counter culture. They made it clear that if the Church does not become the observers of the Kingdom values and the symbol of ethical community then it would become the reflection of injustice, oppressive and exploitative structure and inequalities. John Chrysostom in his 12th homily on Matthew says,

… the very heathens disbelieve the things that we say, since our doings, not our sayings, 
     are the demonstration which they are willing to receive from us; and when they see 
    us building ourselves fine houses, … they are not willing to believe that we are 
   preparing for another sort of residence away from our city. (Nicene and Post-
   Nicene Fathers (First Series) Vol. 10, p. 79)

Hence according to him ethical life of the Church is a missiological necessity.

Conclusion


Many of the present ecclesiological understanding undermine the real nature and function of the Church. They view Church as an institutionalized, structuralized and beaurocratic organization. In such an understanding laws, regulations and power politics become the normative factors. Present understanding relegates the Church as an organization of individualistic, personalized and materialistic spirituality that is emotionally charged and egoistically motivated rather than motivated by Kingdom concerns. Under such an attitude Church views its existence only in an other-worldly nature and becomes indifferent to the world, its needs and problems. For the Church that misinterpreted an imminent kingdom and lived indifferent to the world, a corrective measure of presenting Church as the witness of the Kingdom was provided by the Early Church Fathers. These ecclesiological visions helped the Church to grow firmly on the Kingdom vision and its values. Hence these understandings are relevant for today also. The understanding of the eternal, mystical and eschatological nature of the Church is instrumental in transcending the Church from becoming a captive of historical developments. At the same time ecclesiological perceptions of Church as the witness of the Kingdom, harmonious community in Christ etc prompted the Church not to fall into an escapist attitude but to creatively confront the historical context. Understanding of Church as an ethical community advocates the Church to challenge the world being a counter culture. In short the vision of the Early Fathers presents us with mature ecclesiological understanding, that excel with the missiological vision that outshine the limitation of historical epochs.





1










No comments: